posted on Saturday, July 22, 2006 10:28 AM by mexikali luchadoria

Lebanon

Okay, so I had made this long post about my views on the Lebanese and Israeli conflict, but then I realized, I was really just trying to say the following: I feel really bad for people on both sides of this conflict. I doubt there will be a peaceful resolution. I find it ironic that both participants to date are democracies.

In a side note, the whole concept of "democracy" means a different thing to the average US citizen and those of other democracies.  We have a wierd system. We do not vote for a tiered parliament, which then based on proportions of votes garnered therein elects a cabinet and then a prime minister and a president. Instead, we use the spoils system and a direct election of the president and our congressional members with a rubber stamp electoral college for the presidency. (The electoral college was supposed to be its own decision making body, now of course the electoral college rubber stamps which way a state went under the two party system). It makes our government really strong, but it leads to a two party system. As long as the majority of the United States electorate tends toward the moderate middle, the government is much more stable here than in a parliamentary system. And with stability, comes long-term power. It would be interesting to see if our mode of democracy would work in other places. I doubt it would.

And in a final note, I am curious if a democratic government has ever flourished in a place without a large middle class. I shall have to research this and see.

Comments

# re: Lebanon @ Saturday, July 22, 2006 11:21 AM

India's had a functioning democracy for 50 years and is just now developing a middle class.

baal

# re: Lebanon @ Saturday, July 22, 2006 1:12 PM

I wouldn't really consider Hezbollah a democracy, since they're the ones waging hostilities against Israel and not Lebanon's puppet democracy. Considering the Lebanese government is "banned" from Hezbollah-controlled areas, it doesn't seem too clear cut as a democracy vs. democracy conflict.

The Evil Randar

# re: Lebanon @ Sunday, July 23, 2006 11:39 AM

Also it's odd that you would find two democracies fighting ironic. As that isn't ironic.

baal